Locked Up

There’s an ancient debate among theological circles between the ideas of God’s sovereignty and man’s free will as they are presented in the Scriptures. If you’re not familiar with this, don’t dig too deeply…trust me, your faith will be damaged. The crux of the infighting, though, is an attempt to decipher if what happens in our lives is the result of our own independent choices, or if we are simply puppets with God pulling the strings.

Personally, I sway to the (almost extreme) end of our free choice. I won’t bore anyone with the reasons why, because by now you know my distaste for theological hate…oops, I mean debate. I’m wondering lately, though, about how this plays into the concept of fear.

Specifically, my fear is of our government of late and the freedoms that I remember us once having that we give so freely away now (for more comment on this, see my Newsvine column…link on my sidebar). I’m not really an activist at heart, though, so I have to find something to do with the fear that I feel. I know many others with different fears: fears that past mistakes will return to bite them (don’t we all have that?), fear that their significant others really are cheating, fear that their job could vanish from beneath them…most of us have felt these at some point in our lives, a realization that there is no such thing as security, or at least that we can’t create such an animal. That being the case, do we completely take our hands off of the proverbial wheel and let life go where it will? If we can be confident (my assertion is that we can) that our choices hold the key to the ramifications in our lives…physical, emotional, and spiritual…then doesn’t the age-old argument that “God has it all under control” lose its weight?

Somehow I’m attempting to reconcile that in my head. My gut says no, that He still does, but that if we’re hell-bent on screwing things up, He’ll let us. Of course, He still can make good come out of our screw-ups. Still, however, I’m left with fear, and with that fear comes bondage.

I think America is existing in the bondage of fear right now, so part of that is cultural in nature. As free as I may feel, though, it stands to reason that I’m being held back from my potential by these latent fears of family, friends, and country that lurk in the dark recesses of my spirit. Feeling free and realizing that you’re not is an exasperating sensation, one for which I don’t have an answer.

Perhaps, though, an acceptance of paradoxes is at its core, believing that two contradictory metaphysical elements can simultaneously occur and exist within our lives. It seems to me that we must accept these at some level, because God is (or at least appears to our finite little brains to be) paradoxical at times. Which leaves us with a choice: we can either become arrogant theologians who presume to think that they can ascend to understanding at some point, or we can opt on the side of faith and accept the mystery of our spiritual existence.

I don’t have much taste for the first, and I’m finding that mystery is one of life’s…and God’s…most beautiful qualities.

The Objectifying of (Miss) America

So, there’s much hype as always about the new Miss America being crowned at what CNN labels a “jazzed-up pageant.” Another beautiful young woman will now have the opportunity to travel and speak about her platform, in exchange for objectifying herself in front of a nationwide television audience.

Was that critical? Oops.

Perhaps part of my issue that I can’t stand fake things, and there’s something about beauty pageants that screams fake to me (could it be the plastic smiles or the tragically uneducated answers? Perhaps…). Don’t get me wrong, I’m happy for the winners in the sense that they have a chance to advocate some (typically) worthwhile causes and that they win scholarship money and all, but I think my real issue is with the objectification.

I love beauty. I appreciate looking at beautiful women. I’m heartbroken, however, at how the path to success and fortune for beautiful women in America’s entertainment industry is marked by putting their bodies on display for whomever may want to lust after them along the way, and forever and ever at that, as pictures never come off the Internet once they’re on. I’ve talked about my opinion of the entertainment industry here before; about how there shouldn’t be an industry, and how it has succeeded in destroying many a young celebrity along the way, most notably, of late, being Britney Spears. There’s a line where any good thing becomes gratuitous. The long-term effects of women (or men) placing their bodies on display in order to move up the ladder of success is damaging beneath its flashy veneer, and the concept is, at its core, a very voyeuristic and twisted idea. It moves us all, both those who look and those are looked upon, into a realm of captivity of sorts. Ironic in my mind that it is considered a freedom.

Don’t get me wrong: I’m not some hyper-conservative religious fundamentalist who thinks that women must cover themselves from head to toe. I’m just recognizing that something changes when we take a beautiful woman wearing a bikini on the beach or an evening gown at dinner, and place her under the stage lights for everyone to gaze upon. Outside of the context of story, I can’t help but think that this moves into the realm of the gratuitous, just like when artistic nudity is replaced with pornography.

Why is that we cannot hold pageants based upon intellect, and public speaking ability, and social activism along with beauty? Why can we not have more discussion and less modeling? Might that not do something to advance us culturally, instead of leaving us in the realm of vacuous prime time entertainment?

The problem is, I think, that our standards are low enough that we legitimately desire that vacuous entertainment. And that’s indicative of a much, much deeper issue.

The Death of Storytelling, Part 2

Some further reflection on this idea came up during conversations tonight, primarily the connection between the passing away of the art of (personal) storytelling, and the difficulty of our age with having faith.

Go back with me for a moment to the ancients, who lived like 900 years according to Biblical accounts. I imagine it would be much easier to have faith in something like the creation narrative when you had someone talking to you who had been there a few hundred years before. You can argue logic, science, and theory all day, but you really cannot argue with someone’s personal experience.

Karen told me today about a family we know, the father in whom had difficulty relaying to his children stories from his past. It was a huge event for them when he finally did so, and, in fact, they felt deprived of something until he began. Our faith was initially passed on orally, and the spoken word held so much power in nearly every culture for centuries. Now that we have attempted to replace that with something meant to augment it or walk alongside it (i.e.: the visual), we have become much more prone to fall into the realm of strict objectivity. This is a deadly cause of harmful forms of doubt as we are faced with shorter and shorter life spans. I find it difficult to even imagine Vietnam. When I no longer have my father’s stories to paint a picture of it in my mind, that ability to accurately imagine it will grow even more dim. I could easily see how history can be forgotten with this effect. Already we have those who claim that the Holocaust never occurred.

If we lose our passion for telling the story, then we lose the primary evidence we have for believing that history happened: personal experiences. Even generations removed, the accurate re-telling of someone’s personal experiences, even if they are long since passed away, hold enormous power. Similarly, the records of Christ’s life hold power to us today. God did not inspire writers for no reason.

Further, we have to turn from the the fact that we have forsaken instilling a love for fantasy and magic and miracles in our children for the instilling a love for objective science. No wonder it is difficult for us to believe in miracles when we haven’t grown up being told that the fantastic and unexplainable can, in fact, happen. Thus, we make the fatal leap in logic that a miracle cannot occur because we’ve never seen one (“a virgin can’t have a baby…when have you ever seen that happen?”).

To illustrate truth, Jesus used fiction. He told parables to paint what He needed to say about life. How is it that we have grown so obsessed with analyzing that life that we’ve forgotten the way He modeled perpetuating it? If we don’t re-discover this passion, I tremble for our future. I truly, truly do.

The Death of Storytelling

During the time I’ve worked with adolescents, I’ve discovered a frightening dis-interest in reading or communicating experiences. I remember a high school student saying about Scriptures to me at one point that, “If it were a movie, I’d watch it.” Don’t get me wrong, I love film, but we can never permit it to replace literature.

Something else I’ve noticed as a disturbing trend is how adolescents have a horrible distaste for writing, or re-telling what has happened to them. Instead of using the ability to post photos or video of an event to assist others in experiencing their story, the desire to tell the story has been completely replaced by posting photos or video. The next generation has lost its desire to tell stories.

Now, I’m generalizing a great deal. I’m worked with and know many of that age who don’t fall into the problem of which I’m writing here. I’m speaking as a rule, though. Listen to the average middle school (or jr. high, depending on your locale) student when asked to write a story from their lives. Talk about a deer-in-headlights look.

What would the world look like if we lost the art of story telling? I don’t mean documentary recording, I mean story telling. Even the Scriptures were first primarily transmitted orally. I fear it is something that may die in our culture if we don’t do something to resuscitate it, and quickly.

I was grilling out with some family this weekend. While standing on my uncle’s deck, we became engaged in conversation with my uncle’s neighbor, who was also grilling out on his deck (don’t you just love suburbia?). This guy was a missionary, and had a million stories to tell. He said that his wife was a writer (just as I was about to offer my ghostwriting services) and planned to record his memoirs some day. I hope they do.

Or my grandfather on my wife’s side, who has tremendous war stories to tell, and who we may not have much longer. To have a life pass is not that tragic with the certainty that we will see that person again. But to lose the stories…our culture will suffer for that.

There is a private library where we live that has many letters and diaries and journals from those long since gone. Karen loves to go there and explore…she even did a paper on it in grad school. At first I thought it wasn’t really my thing, but how amazing to have those stories preserved.

Every life forever alters history, and irrevocably touches those around it. To honor that life by preserving its story must be the highest respect we can pay. If we lose our cultural aptitude for telling the story, we will have lost our link to our past, and, to overuse a cliche, be doomed to repeat it. We would also lose the fascination for telling fictional stories, one of humanity’s greatest creative endeavors. We would have lost so much, and it would be so difficult to regain.

What do we do to prevent this from happening? Well, the education system doesn’t seem to be working, so who knows. Perhaps spending time with people instead of working two jobs, or placing our elderly in nursing homes instead of listening to them. Whatever it is, we must do it quickly, or be forced to treat the literary casualties of a generation.